The Days of Our Lives cast did it again! Keeping the fun behind-the-scenes content coming, the official show Instagram page just unveiled a new reel where several cast members were asked to choose at least three co-stars they’d invite to Thanksgiving dinner, and some of their answers might surprise you.

Kicking things off was Paul Telfer (Xander Kiriakis), who said he’d invite Suzanne (Maggie), Linsey (Sarah), and Stacy (Kristen). His reason? They all eat “tiny, tiny amounts of food,” and of course, he was only joking.

Next up was Abigail Klein (Stephanie Johnson). Her Thanksgiving trio included Mary Beth (Kayla), because she could cook all the treats and bake all the cookies, plus JP (Philip) and Rob (Alex).

Then we moved over to Martha Madison (Belle Black), who revealed she already has a Thanksgiving invite list: Tina Huang (Melinda), Deidre Hall (Marlena), Emily O’Brien (Gwen)… and her fiancé, of course.

Linsey Godfrey (Sarah) followed with a clever workaround. She said she’d strategically stack all the women from the show on three chairs so she wouldn’t have to pick favorites—because choosing between them would be like picking her favorite child… and she only has one. She insisted there are simply too many amazing women on the show to choose just three.

Who Are You Inviting to Thanksgiving?

Newest cast addition Conner Floyd (Chad DiMera) kept it simple (and a bit mischievous): Dan (EJ), Eric (Brady), and Brandon Beemer (Shawn), because he feels like getting into a little trouble.

As for Cherie Jimenez (Gabi), she went straight for the Hernandez clan: Al (Javi), Galen (Rafe), and Marissa (Ari).

Sal Stowers (Lani) couldn’t keep her list to three even if she tried. She kicked off with Marci Miller (ex-Abby), then added Stacy Haiduk, Linsey Godfrey, her girl Heather (behind the camera), Raven (Chanel), Elia (Jada), Jackée (Paulina), AnnaLynne (Cat), Cherie, Mary Beth… basically all the ladies. She summed it up perfectly: a girls’ Thanksgiving would be fun.

Tyler Joseph Andrews (Theo) kept things straightforward with his choices: James (Abe), Dan (EJ), and Casey (JJ).

Greg Rikaart gave us the “gossip squad”, listing Emily O’Brien, Jackée, Deidre, and Peter Porte (Dimitri), saying they’d “just gossip dish” all night.

Closing out the video was Dan Feuerriegel (EJ), who delivered the most relatable answer of all, although just or fun: “No one. I’m going to eat all that stuff myself.”