In Emmerdale, no villain leaves quietly, and John Sugden’s time in the Dales appears to be running short. His crimes have shocked fans, from the murder of Nate Robinson to his brutal attack on Mackenzie Boyd. Now, with actor Oliver Farnworth’s departure already confirmed, viewers are asking one question: who will take John down?

Theories are flying across social media, and even bookies are weighing in with odds on the most likely scenario. The question isn’t if John will exit Emmerdale — it’s how, and who will deliver his comeuppance.

Robert Sugden Leads the Pack

At the top of the suspect list is Robert Sugden. As John’s estranged half-brother, Robert has more reason than most to seek revenge. Fans know Robert has never shied away from violence when pushed, and the thought of him returning to deal with John once and for all has electrified speculation. Bookies have him at Evens — the clear favourite to end John’s reign of terror in a fit of family-fueled rage.

If Robert takes justice into his own hands, it would be a classic Emmerdale move: emotional, shocking, and deeply personal. Could his comeback deliver one of the show’s most explosive exits yet?

Aaron Dingle’s Breaking Point

Close behind Robert is Aaron Dingle, sitting at 2/1 odds. Aaron’s life has been defined by heartbreak, loss, and trauma. To discover that John played a role in Nate’s death could push him over the edge. Fans have watched Aaron battle demons before, and the idea of him snapping again feels tragically believable.

Some even suggest Aaron might not act alone. With the Dingles known for rallying around family, Cain Dingle enters the conversation too. At 3/1, Cain’s reputation as the village hard man makes him a credible candidate to settle the score permanently.

Could the Law Catch Up?

Of course, not every soap storyline ends in bloodshed. Odds of 6/4 suggest John could simply be arrested. Given his violent history and Mack still being held captive, police intervention would make sense. But while realistic, fans often prefer a more dramatic send-off than handcuffs and a prison van.

Another possibility is that John flees the village entirely. With odds at 5/2, this option would allow him to escape justice temporarily, leaving the door open for a surprise return down the line.

Wildcards and Soap Twists

No soap is complete without wild theories, and Emmerdale fans have plenty. Some believe John could meet his end in an unexpected way, with Chas Dingle stepping in at 5/1 odds. Others speculate Anthony Fox may still be alive, returning at 7/1 for a revenge twist that no one saw coming.

And then there’s the most tantalising rumour: John isn’t really a Sugden at all. At 4/7, the odds are strong enough to suggest a reveal is possible. Could everything we know about him be built on a lie?

One Thing Is Certain

Whether it’s prison, payback, or a shocking unmasking, John Sugden’s exit is set to deliver high drama. Emmerdale thrives on explosive goodbyes, and this storyline promises no less.

As TV critic Vivian Summers summed it up: “Whether it’s prison, payback or a panto-style unmasking, one thing is certain: nobody in Emmerdale leaves quietly.”

Fans should brace themselves — because John’s downfall is coming, and the only mystery left is who will deliver the final blow.